Explore how the cost-to-cost method for percentage of completion works in construction contracts, why costs incurred reflect work performed, and why stored or uninstalled materials are excluded. Learn how this affects revenue recognition and project accounting in construction financial management.

Multiple Choice

In the cost-to-cost method of percentage of completion, which item should be excluded from the calculation?

In the cost-to-cost method, the percentage of completion is calculated by dividing costs incurred to date by the total estimated costs to complete the contract. Only costs that reflect work actually performed on the project should be included in the numerator. Labor costs, overhead allocations, and equipment depreciation are costs incurred in moving toward completion, so they belong in the calculation. Stored materials and materials that have been purchased but not yet installed are still inventory and have not contributed to work performed; including them would overstate progress and distort revenue recognition. Therefore, stored materials and uninstalled materials are excluded from the calculation.

The hidden math behind construction revenue is more than math—it’s about honesty in recognizing progress. When projects drag on for months or years, you need a reliable way to measure how far along you are. The cost-to-cost method, a staple in the percentage-of-completion family, does just that by tying revenue to the actual costs incurred as work advances. But not every number that slides across your ledger should be part of that progress gauge. Here’s the practical, real-world sense of what counts—and, crucially, what doesn’t.

The core idea: how progress is measured

In the cost-to-cost approach, progress is a ratio. You take the costs incurred to date and compare them to the total estimated costs to complete the contract. Revenue and gross profit are then recognized in proportion to that ratio. It’s a way of saying, “We’ve paid this much, so we’ve earned this much,” with the caveat that the costs included should reflect value actually added by the work performed.

That means you’re not just tallying every dollar that leaves the company’s cash register. You’re counting costs that represent work that has moved the project forward. This distinction between costs that reflect real progress and costs that don’t is where the subtleties come in. Some categories clearly push progress forward; others tend to inflate it if counted too early or in the wrong way.

What counts as cost (the straightforward part)

In practice, most of the typical project costs do end up in the numerator of the progress calculation. That includes:

  • Labor costs: Wages, benefits, and payroll taxes for workers who are actively performing construction tasks on the project.

  • Overhead allocations: A portion of the company’s indirect costs associated with running the project, such as supervision, site office expenses, and proportionate utilities.

  • Equipment depreciation: The wear-and-tear cost assigned to equipment used to perform the work, allocated over the period it’s used on site.

  • Materials used in the work: The actual materials that become part of the project as they are installed.

These items reflect real, on-site activity that pushes the project toward completion. They’re costs that represent the progress you’ve made and are generally consistent with the logic of the cost-to-cost calculation.

The tricky exclusion: stored and uninstalled materials

Here’s where the nuance matters. Not every cost tied to the project should be treated as progress toward completion. Stored materials and uninstalled materials—while they are assets on the balance sheet and part of the project’s overall cost—do not yet reflect work performed. They’re inventory, waiting to be turned into finished work. Counting them in the progress calculation would overstate how much of the project has actually been completed.

Think of it this way: you’ve bought materials, but unless and until those materials are installed and become a functional part of the project, they haven’t contributed to the completed work. Including them inflates the numerator and distorts revenue recognition. So, in the cost-to-cost method, stored materials and uninstalled materials are excluded from the calculation. They remain assets on the balance sheet until they’re used.

The practical impact of the exclusion

  • Revenue recognition timing: By excluding stored and uninstalled materials, the approach avoids recognizing revenue for work that hasn’t been performed yet. This keeps financial statements honest and aligned with the actual progress on the site.

  • Inventory management discipline: The rule nudges project teams to track the flow of materials carefully—from purchase to storage to installation—so that costs are matched with the right stage of work.

  • Forecast sensitivity: As projects update their total estimated costs to complete, the denominator shifts. Excluding stored materials from the numerator makes those updates reflect genuine on-site progress rather than pre-purchased stock.

A quick mental model

Imagine you’re building a bridge. You’ve paid crews, bought steel, rented cranes, and placed some concrete. Some of that concrete is already poured and curing; some steel racks are waiting in a yard, and a pile of cables sits unused in a trailer. The costs tied to the poured concrete, the crews actively working, and the crane’s hours ticking away move you closer to completion. The steel in the yard and the cables waiting for installation don’t yet move the needle in the same way. They’re real costs, but they don’t represent work performed. That’s why you exclude stored and uninstalled materials.

Digging a little deeper: practical guidelines you’ll see in the field

  • Regularly update the total estimated cost to complete: This is a moving target. If the project’s scope changes, or productivity shifts, the denominator changes, which can alter the percentage of completion.

  • Distinguish costs incurred vs. costs paid: The calculation hinges on costs incurred (not just cash outlay). Accrual accounting can help align with when the work actually happens, not when the check clears.

  • Keep a clean material status ledger: Track material purchases, inventory status, and installation milestones. This makes it easier to decide when a cost should enter the numerator versus staying outside it.

  • Align with project controls: Project managers and cost accountants should collaborate closely. The line between “cost to perform” and “cost to hold” can blur if the reporting isn’t synchronized.

A practical example (numbers just to illustrate)

Let’s say a project has an initial estimate of 1,000,000 total costs to complete. To date, costs incurred amount to 300,000. Of that, 90,000 covers labor actually performed on-site, 40,000 covers overhead allocated to the project, 50,000 is for equipment depreciation tied to on-site use, and 60,000 is for materials that have been installed. There’s also 20,000 worth of stored materials that haven’t been installed yet.

  • Costs incurred to date (inclusive) = 300,000

  • Excluded costs (stored materials) = 20,000

  • Included costs (for progress) = 280,000

Progress percentage = 280,000 / 1,000,000 = 28%

Revenue recognized would then be 28% of the total contract value, subject to other accounting considerations. Notice how the 20,000 stored materials don’t boost the progress percentage, keeping the recognition honest and tied to actual on-site progress.

Common pitfalls to avoid

  • Automatically counting every purchased material: It’s tempting to bundle all costs into progress, but if nothing is installed yet, that material isn’t progress—skip it.

  • Letting estimates lag: If you don’t refresh the total estimated cost to complete, you risk mis-stating progress. Regular reviews are essential.

  • Mixing project types: Some contracts have buyouts, long lead items, or design-build components. Each element can affect how costs are categorized in the percentage calculation.

Why this matters beyond the numbers

For construction finance professionals, the clarity of measurement isn’t just a bookkeeping concern. It affects cash flow planning, lender communications, and the project’s perceived health. When progress is measured accurately, it’s easier to forecast financing needs, schedule risk reviews, and negotiate changes with stakeholders. The discipline around excluding stored and uninstalled materials isn’t a dry rule; it’s a guardrail that helps keep the project’s financial story straight.

A few more angles to consider

  • Tax and financial reporting alignment: Different jurisdictions may have nuanced rules about revenue recognition. The core idea—count only work actually performed—helps align with generally accepted accounting principles and tax considerations.

  • Industry practices vary by sector: In heavy civil versus private development, the mix of costs and timing of material installation can tilt how aggressively you recognize progress. The principle remains the same, but the practical application might look a bit different.

  • Technology can help: Construction ERP systems and project controls software can automate much of the tracking, flagging materials that are purchased but not installed and preventing them from creeping into the progress calculation.

A note on the bigger picture

The cost-to-cost method is one way to tell the story of a project’s progress. It sits alongside other methods like the input-based approaches and more milestone-driven recognition. Each method has its place, but the key is transparency—making sure that what’s reported truly reflects the work completed, not just what’s been paid for or stored away.

Why it’s worth getting right

For anyone involved in the financial heartbeat of a construction project, getting the inclusion criteria right isn’t just about compliance. It’s about credibility—reducing surprises, improving decision-making, and communicating a trustworthy picture to lenders, partners, and the project team. When you exclude stored materials from the progress numerator, you’re doing the honest thing: you’re counting only what you’ve built, not what you’ve bought in advance.

If you’re new to this arena, take heart: the logic is straightforward once you see the lines that separate progress from kept-in-advance inventory. It’s a small distinction with a big ripple effect, especially in larger, longer-duration projects where the pace of installation can swing with weather, supply chain quirks, or design changes.

Final takeaway

In the cost-to-cost method of measuring percentage of completion, the item that should be excluded from the calculation is stored materials and uninstalled materials. They represent inventory—not completed work—and including them would exaggerate progress. Everything else—labor, overhead allocations, equipment depreciation, and materials actually installed—belongs in the progress calculation. It’s a practical rule that keeps the financial story aligned with the work performed, and that’s the backbone of trustworthy project accounting.